Accountability Denied: Bangladesh’s Engagement with International Human Rights Bodies on Enforced Disappearances
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14992113Keywords:
Enforced Disappearance, Human Rights Committee, Committee Against Torture, Bangladesh, State Party Report, Concluding ObservationsAbstract
This article examines Bangladesh’s interaction with international human rights mechanisms, especially the ICCPR, CAT, UPR, and WGEID, highlighting the issue of enforced disappearances. The analysis applying Creamer and Simmons’ framework of elite socialization, learning and capacity building, domestic mobilization, and law development reveals persistent state denial, mislabeling of crimes, and rejection of recommendations. Despite treaty obligations, Bangladesh’s government dismissed allegations as politically motivated, refused to criminalize enforced disappearance and evaded scrutiny. While civil society efforts and international pressure increased visibility, systemic repression, and judicial inaction stifled accountability. The study underscores the limitations of non-binding mechanisms in authoritarian contexts, where political will determines compliance. The 2024 interim government’s ratification of ICPPED signals potential reform, yet meaningful progress hinges on domestic legal reforms and dismantling institutionalized impunity.
References
Amnesty International, Universal Periodic Review of Bangladesh: Amnesty International’s mid-term assessment of progress towards implementation of recommendations accepted at the third review (Index: ASA 13/4732/2021 2021) 11-12.
Bari M E, ‘The Use Of Enforced Disappearance In Bangladesh As A Tool Of Political Oppression: Human Rights In Retreat’ (2021) 29(3) Michigan State University Law Review 414.
Conrad C R and Moore W H, ‘What Stops the Torture?’ (2010) 54(2) American Journal of Political Science 461-463.
Crawford J, ‘The UN Human Rights Treaty System: A System in Crisis?’ in Philip Alston and James Crawford (eds), The Future Of Un Human Rights Treaty Monitoring (CUP 2000) 1, 3.
Creamer C D and Simmons B A, ‘The Dynamic Impact of Periodic Review on Women's Rights’ (2018) 81 Law and Contemporary Problems 31.
Creamer C D and Simmons B A, ‘The Proof Is in The Process: Self-Reporting Under International Human Rights Treaties’ (2020) 114(1) American Journal of International Law 1.
Hafner-Burton E, Making Human Rights A Reality (Princeton University Press 2013).
HRFB, Civil Society Report on the Implementation of the ICCPR- Contribution to the List of Issues (HRFB 2015).
Human Rights Watch, “We Don’t Have Him” Secret Detentions and Enforced Disappearances in Bangladesh (HRW 2017) .
Human Rights Watch, “Where No Sun Can Enter” A Decade of Enforced Disappearances in Bangladesh (HRW 2021).
Human Rights Watch, World Report 2023 (HRW 2023).
International Commission of Jurists, No More “Missing Persons”: The Criminalization of Enforced Disappearance in South Asia (ICJ 2017).
Khalil T, Jallad: Death Squads and State Terror in South Asia (Pluto Press 2015).
Malek A, ‘State Responsibilities and the Combatting Against Forced Disappearance in Bangladesh: Institutional and Legal Challenges’ (2024) 16(4) Pakistan Journal of Criminology 1407.
NHRC, JAMAKON Report to the UN Human Rights Committee (NHRC 2016).
O’Flaherty M, ‘The Concluding Observations of United Nations Human Rights Treaty Bodies’ (2006) 6 Human Rights Law Review 27.
OHCHR, Human Rights Violations and Abuses related to the Protests of July and August 2024 in Bangladesh (OHCHR, 2025)
Rana E K and MoIslam M J, ‘NGO Discourses of Extrajudicial Killings and Enforced Disappearances in Bangladesh’ (2021) 16(1) International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences 110-126.
Riaz A, Where Are They? Enforced Disappearances in Bangladesh (CGS 2022).
Riaz A and Rana M S, How Autocrats Rise: Sequences of Democratic Backsliding (Palgrave Macmillan 2024).
Sarkar M N and Islam M, ‘Enforced Disappearance In Defiance Of Human Rights: A Critical Review Of Legal And Institutional Aspects From Bangladesh Perspective’ (2013) 13(1, 2) Bangladesh Journal of Law 105.
Simmons B A, Mobilizing for Human Rights: International Law in Domestic Politics (CUP 2009).
Sourav R I, ‘Defining the Crime of Enforced Disappearance in Conformity with International Criminal Law: a New Frontier for Bangladesh’ (2015) 3(2) Bergen Journal of Criminal Law & Criminal Justice 1-23.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Law and Society Students' Journal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
